Breastfeeding - Handling Criticism


Feelings about how to parent seem to shift with every generation.  A new way of parenting, sometimes called attachment parenting, has emerged and it challenges many of the rigid teachings of our mother's generation.  Although breastfeeding is on the rise now, women are still dealing with the repercussions of previous generations.  Not too long ago mainstream women did not breastfeed at all and the ones that did were taught to follow strict schedules.

Some thought of breastfeeding as primitive.  Formula was touted as being equal to or superior to breast milk. Only recently, has the fact that "breast is best" been acknowledged.  Other women were in the workforce.  They may have felt that breastfeeding was not an option for them.  They did not have the modern breast pump available to them.  The medical community may not have encouraged breastfeeding at the time.  It is not hard to imagine.  After all, even with all the knowledge about the benefits of breastfeeding there are still many health professionals today that are uneducated and unsupportive of breastfeeding.  With all the challenges in the way of breastfeeding, it is understandable why many women of yesterday did not choose to breastfeed.

Breastfeeding has come a long way but still many of the old thinking still carries on.  Women are more educated on the subject; however, even with the many books and other information available, people are often most influenced by their immediate family and friends.  Having the support of friends and family can boost the chances of having a successful breastfeeding experience.  On the other hand, having to deal with criticism and misinformation from the people you are close to can sabotage a new mom trying to breastfeed.

There are many ways to deal with the negativity of others.  One of the best things you can do is to try to understand why the person feels the way they do.  Is it because they were taught differently about breastfeeding?  Were they indoctrinated with the ideas that breastfeeding is primitive or inferior?  Or is it that they feel breasts are a sexual object?  Maybe they have never seen someone breastfeed and it makes them uncomfortable.  This is the case with a lot of people.  Once breastfeeding in public becomes more commonplace, perhaps, this will become less of a problem.  Whatever the case, finding out the root of the person's issues with breastfeeding may help to resolve the tension.

Here are some things you can do to deal with criticism.

Be positive:  It is hard for someone to argue with a happy, positive person.  If you are excited and enthusiastic about breastfeeding it can be contagious

Try to educate them:  Find information on the benefits of breastfeeding to mom and baby and share this with them.  You don't have to "push this down their throat".  Just be enthusiastic about your decision to breastfeed and share with them why you decided to.

Be sympathetic:  A lot of times women are defensive because breastfeeding did not work out for them.  If you sit and talk with any woman that really wanted to breastfeed, you can hear the sadness in her story.  Try to be sympathetic and non-judgmental.  Don't say things like "you could have or should have".  Share your experience, be positive, and let them know you care.

Try not to get angry:  Breastfeeding conversations can get very heated.  Getting angry with someone is not likely to change her feelings.  It will just make you and her upset.  If you don't feel like you can talk about breastfeeding with this person change the subject or avoid talking about it.

Use your doctor as your advocate:  Sometimes the best thing you can do is tell someone that this is what your doctor recommends.  What you think means very little to some people but a doctor's word carries weight. 

Don't be sarcastic or insulting:  Belittling someone is likely to make someone defensive.  It is not a good approach to winning someone over.  You may turn an opportunity to educate someone into a personal attack.

Stand your ground:  Do not let someone else decide how you are going to parent.  If they are uncomfortable then they will have to come to terms with it.  You do not have to change the way you parent to suit someone else.

If nothing is working then you may just let the person know that you do not want to discuss the issue with them any more.  Hopefully, it doesn't come to this.

No votes yet


Sign in to leave a comment!

Today on JustMommies

Power Your Busy Days with Protein (Sponsored)

We're all familiar with those days where it's difficult to squeeze in balanced meals, or any meal at all. Between running errands and keeping the kids on schedule, we are all in need of a grab and go snack to get us through the day.

Legitimate Ways to Work from Home: Ideas and Tips

If you've thought about working from home, you may have wondered what you could do and how to avoid being scammed. You may have thought that there just aren't any legitimate work-at-home jobs out there...

How to Find a Summer Camp Your Child Will Love

For kids, summer means getting a break from school. While they usually enjoy the break at first, they may soon get bored of having nothing to do.

3 Looks That Look Great Post-Workout (Sponsored)

CALIA by Carrie Underwood allows women to feel strong and beautiful whether they’re working out or running errands. This new fitness lifestyle collection, available exclusively at DICK’S Sporting Goods, aims to make women feel confident and comfortable, while maintaining their personal style.


From The Message Boards

Attachment Parenting


I heard something today that gave me pause. A person was telling me howtheir child had said the F wo...

Attachment Parenting

My baby is walking!

Not even 9 months old and L let go of the couch tonight and just kept going! !...

Attachment Parenting

Hiring a nanny

Hi everyone, I haven't been around much... sorry! I know though that there are a few mommys on here...

Attachment Parenting

That moment when someone gives your kid a stupid nickname....

I think there was a thread on this earlier but I just have to vent. Does it annoy anyone else when s...

Attachment Parenting

Co-Sleeping question

I am new to AP, but think it is the route I want to take with baby #2. I think I was somewhat AP wit...