Crying It Out: Will Holding Your Baby Too Much Spoil Him?

By Nancy Da Silva

Your baby is crying. You’re in the middle of a task in another room, or you’re entertaining company. Do you stop what you’re doing and go pick them up or do you let them cry it out and stay where you are?

The answer to that question, regardless of which you choose, will definitely make you wrong depending on who you talk to.

In one camp are those who attend to their baby every time they cry. They believe that if you don’t pick them up and comfort them when they cry, this will traumatise them and make them feel abandoned and hopeless, feelings that may follow them into adulthood.

In the other camp are those who let their babies cry themselves out. They believe if you run to attend your baby every time they cry this will make your baby impatient and greedy for your attention. They will become spoiled children who in turn will become spoiled adults.

There seem to be sound arguments for both sides. So who’s right and who’s wrong?

For a new mom, the question is a frightening one. We’ve all been at the receiving end of well meaning advice from relatives, many times contradictory but never so much as when that first baby comes along.

Your emotions are out of whack from the recent pregnancy, you’re on little sleep and you are now supposed to care for this tiny, helpless infant. At this point, there is nothing someone can tell you that will be as devastating as calling you a bad mother.

You look to those moms around you for advice and don’t want to be looked down for not following their suggestions. And let’s not kid ourselves; those other mothers can be pretty intimidating when showering you with advice. By the end of it you’re amazed you can even figure out how to put your baby’s diaper on right without their help.

Ashley, a 26 year old from Frankfort, KY believes that it’s important to pick up your baby when he cries. “Lots of parents believe that constantly responding to your child's cries immediately can lead to co dependency issues that can cause negative effects later in life.  In my opinion, for the first year you can't spoil a baby.  Babies need closeness and warmth, love and nurturing. They need to know that they are loved and they need to build trust in you.  Babies cry to communicate their needs, even if all they need is your love and attention.  Ignoring a baby's cry can cause them to think that their needs aren't important and can lead to feelings of hopelessness.”

It’s great to have those grandparents around who dote on your baby and love to hold them, even to the point of being disappointed when they have to relinquish him, but is this just setting you up for hard time once they leave?   Your child spent most of the day being held and coddled now you try and set him down and he starts wailing.

Granted, that could try the patience of anyone and your instinct may be to just let him cry out but maybe if you think of his cries as communication, you might learn a different way of looking at things. As an infant, your baby’s cries are his only method to get his needs across. Before picking him up, check to see if he needs something besides simply being held. He might need to be fed or changed or might just need to get used to some kind of different stimuli because for nine months, he’s been connected to you. When he’s born, he’ll see you as the one thing he knows and recognizes in this new world. You can introduce other stimuli into his world by way of music and baby toys. You want to stimulate independent thinking as soon as possible.

While parents can only do what they personally feel is right for their babies, be wary of taking things too far. Joy, a 26 year old from Kentucky USA believes while infants should certainly be picked up when they cry, at a certain point, it’s time to stop rushing at their every whimper. “Under 1 year I believe you should touch them a lot and make sure their needs are always met so they feel safe and secure. But some people take this concept too far. My one friend does AP (attachment parenting) parenting. I have no problem with that, its something I am kinda interested in pursuing if I have child #2, but I think she screwed up somewhere and held her youngest WAY too much. It’s the only child she’s been a SAHM for (youngest of 5).  She breastfeeds, co-sleeps, used to babywear when she was younger, and all of that is okay, but she sits her up on the counter when she’s making dinner. If she’s not driving, she sits in the back right next to her especially on long car trips. She is with her 24/7 and the only person she leaves her with is her husband but one time I got to babysit and it wasn't pretty.

She’s now 16 months and I think a child that age should be really involved in toddling around, playing with toys, learning, etc and be focused on the world around her. In her own house if her mom rounds a corner or goes down the hall, she will stop playing and start crying and toddle run/walk as fast as she can to get her. The only thing that will calm her is usually to be picked up by mom and if it’s real bad, she might even need a nursing session to calm her down.  My daughter is now 3 years old and she never cried and screamed if I went down the hall or in the bathroom at any age. I feel I did something right because she knows I love her and is safe, happy, secure in that knowledge and she can take on the world whether I am there or not.”

So maybe the lesson is pick up your baby when he needs you, but make sure to not do it for so long that there will never be a day when he doesn’t.

Average: 3.5 (32 votes)


By ciara_duffy on 05/15/12 at 2:50 am

definatly agree with ashley, think it all goes back to bowlbys attachment theory. basically your baby needs to know it has a "secure base" which is lovi  ...

By russelmrock on 09/27/11 at 12:08 am

no not at all....

By Natural mommy on 09/26/11 at 7:16 am

This was not really worth the time it took to read. It sounded like she was bashing on AP parents and saying hey I did a great job look at my kid.


Sign in to leave a comment!

Today on JustMommies

DIY Family Project: Woodland Candy Cups

These delightful little candy cups are the perfect fall project to work on with kids. You can collect the leaves on a nature walk together and them come home and make them into candy cups!

Six Myths About Twins

Twins capture the curiosity of the world. From the Spearmint gum twins to Mary Kate and Ashley, seeing double brings amusement and assumptions.

Why Praise is Important for Children

How much praise we give to children is a growing debate in the United States. There are some who say too much praise will give kids a false sense of reality, an inflated ego, or a pride complex.

Top 7 Potty Training Mistakes

So you think you're little one is ready to potty train? If she's been waking up dry in the morning, or has expressed an interest in the potty, or informs you when her diaper is dirty...

From The Message Boards

Baby Signing

What sign do you use?

What sign are you using for when your child needs a diaper change? I see "poop" "diaper" and "change...

Moms of Infants

Have a weekend bonding with your baby

Hi there, I'm new to this forum and I'm glad I've found this site as I can relate to all of you. I'm...