Katie, I can symphathise!! I don't want to scare you, but I didn't O until CD 33. Then AF came early? on CD 44. I don' t know if I took longer to O because of the D&C I had or my body just took a little longer or what. Regardless, waiting to get to your "new normal" is a big pain in the butt and it's not fun. At least you have your sex drive!
As for CM - mine was mostly dry-creamy, i think. To be honest, I don't really remember. I am not great at tracking CM as I would like. I think I know when I finally did O, but that was from my temps and maybe an OPK. My CM was not consistant.
I realize i'm not giving lots of positive experience. But I jsut wanted to let you know you are not alone!!