Hahahaha! This is a funny question. Well if you asked me in first grade, I would have wanted you to call me Donna (after my aunt and much to my mom's dismay). If you asked me in second grade, I wanted to be Rosabelle (I combined Rose and Isabelle).

At one point I wanted to be Karen Kitty, I think that was 4th and 5th grade! LOL NOW, I am completely fine with my name.
If I had been a boy, probably Anthony so people could call me Tony!