Glad to hear your appt. went well!
I don't see any one specific doctor/midwife where I go. It kind of sucks in some aspects but in others it's nice since you get whoever is on duty when you go to deliver. I could see the same person but I'd rather see as many as I can so I've at least met the person who's going to be all up in my business delivering my baby.
Do you have the option to meet with any of them before you commit so that you can ask any questions you might have about how they work and their style of practice? That might help ease some of the pressure of choosing and you might just fall in love with the first one you meet.
I'm shooting for a natural/pain med-free birth but I don't have the option to use a birthing center so I'm stuck with the hospital. I'm not comfortable with a home birth and I think DH would think I was crazy if I brought the idea up to him.

Plus, I like the option of drugs if I end up needing them. I'm just now looking into my options as far as techniques for pain management and things like that. I wish I could do a water birth but the hospital doesn't have tubs.
I have a friend (well, she's more of an acquaintance) that had a natural birth back in October and she's starting classes to become a doula in March so I've asked her about some tips and things she did to prepare so I will be glad to share any of that info with you when she gets back to me, if you'd like.
As far as a birth plan goes, I haven't really thought too far into it at this point other than I'd like to go drug free if I can. I'll look more into that in a month or two probably.