I believe Charlotte is DH's fav... then again he came up with it!

Actually that is the only one on the list he came up with, and he is quite proud.
Now that people have voted, I'll go ahead and throw in what I have always thought... My personal top three were Charlotte, Dahlia, and Alana, in that order. I agree with whoever said that Charlotte is classic whereas Jaelynn is not, so I didn't think it would go, but I was pleasantly surprised by how many people thought otherwise! We were going to go with Alana for that reason, but now I'm thinking twice, especially because DH had to "warm up to it".... he didn't like Alana at first. That and I am more for classic names (I think Alana is the only one on the list that isn't a classic name). As far as Dahlia is concerned, I really love it and love how unique yet familiar it is, but I know our boy name will start with a D, and what if we have a boy next, then the next child after that doesn't get a D name and gets left out.

I know, silly. If we don't use Dahlia this time, it will definitely be in the running next time.
It is funny that some of you said that Charlotte fits us because it is both mine and DH's top pick! And I'm truly surprised that it took until what, post 20, for someone to mention a talking spider.
Anyway, thank you for all of your input! It has definitely made me rethink things a bit... like I said, we were going to go with Alana because of the flow with the middle name even though it wasn't our fav, but now we shall see!