The Pros and Cons to Home Birth

By Maria T. Pepin

As you prepare for birth, one of the choices you will need to make is where to deliver your baby. Women can choose between a hospital, birthing center or the comfort of their own home. It’s a good idea to research each option in advance and make an informed decision. Interestingly, around 16,000 women each year choose to have their baby at home. Let’s take a look at the pros and cons of this approach.  

Home Birth Pros

  • Freedom to control your own birth experience. You can set up your surroundings in a way that you are most comfortable. Some women prefer a water birth or the use of aromatherapies and candles.
  • There is little to no intervention in a homebirth- whether it is having your water broken, electronic fetal monitoring, medication or episiotomies. This is important because once medical intervention is initiated, further intervention will likely be necessary.
  • You have the lowest chance for a C-section at home.
  • There is no huge hospital fee to deal with. A midwife’s fee is usually much less than a physician’s fee.
  • Familiarity of the environment.  You will be more relaxed in the comfort of your own home, which can help ease labor. It is also more private.
  • You have the freedom to eat, drink and move around as much as you’d like. If you check into a hospital, you are only permitted ice chips or popsicles until after the baby is born.
  • You have the lowest risk of infection at home. Hospitals do everything they can to maintain clean wards and control cross-infection, but you are more likely to pick up an infection in that environment given the sheer number of people moving in and out.
  • You can have visitors stop by whenever you’d like, day or night. 

Home Birth Cons

  • Not all insurance policies will cover homebirth expenses.
  • There is no epidural analgesia or pain relief available at home if you are struggling with the labor pains.
  • You will need to be prepared for the messiness of delivery. Make sure you have plastic sheets, plenty of towels, etc. ready to go.
  • Filing for your baby’s birth certificate is now your responsibility, however some midwives will do it for you.
  • Complications can result if your midwife or caregiver is unsure what to do in an emergency situation. Selecting an experienced birthing team is absolutely crucial.
  • If there is an emergency, there will be a delay in receiving care while you travel to the nearest hospital.
  • You will need to arrange for your own postpartum help.

Average: 2.6 (28 votes)


By PurpleTurtle on 02/28/11 at 10:13 am

Chuckle. There is pain relief in a home birth. It is often milder, not heavy drugs that pass the placental barrier and can negatively impact baby as alm  ...

By Sailor Aoki on 07/14/10 at 10:26 pm

"There is no epidural analgesia or pain relief available at home if you are struggling with the labor pains."

When I read this I officially decid  ...

By Labor Maiden on 12/01/09 at 9:01 pm

I have experienced both... Home first then hospital... I was truly overwhelmed with the lack of emotional care and attention after feeling so surrounde  ...

Sign in to leave a comment!

Today on JustMommies

6 Fun & Easy Exercises to Do with Your Kids

With the alarming (and climbing) rate of childhood obesity in the United States, it's more important than ever that parents model healthy behaviors for their children.

5 Things Only Moms of Picky Eaters Will Understand

Your picky eater is all yours, so you love him, of course, but do you ever have those days where you think about how much easier life would be with a kid who just loved to try new foods?

Is Your Child a Natural-Born Liar?

Have you recently caught your little one lying for the first time? Or maybe it’s become a thing now, where your child seems to lying on the regular.

Quick Tips for Choosing the Best Summer Camp

Whether you’re looking for a camp where your child can enjoy outdoor adventure, or one where he or she can play rock ‘n roll music, pickin’ the right one should be stress-free.

From The Message Boards

VBAC: Vaginal Birth After a Caesarean

Anyone like to join me?! Board revival.

Hello! My name is Erin and I am pregnant with my second child. My due date is Valentine's day 2017....

Pregnancy Loss

i miss my twin

I requested my medical records and my last baby was a twin but one didn't make it I had 2 amo sacks...

Baby Names

WDYT about the name....

Arlo. We were team green with our last baby and this was the boy name we had picked out for her. W...

Getting Ready for Baby

Anyone get a free Amazon Baby Welcome box?

Has anyone recently gotten an ? Just curious what you have gotten. The reviews/pictures look quite d...

Pregnancy Over 35

I'm pregnant after Cancer...

Hey all, so I fit into a lot of categories on these boards. High Risk, after loss and What in the Wo...