The Best Damn Lactation Cookies You’ll Ever Eat


Now, I am the first person to admit that cooking is not my forte. In fact the closest my celebrity has ever come to a celebrity chef is being the warm up comic for a pilot that Paula Dean was a guest on. And just for the record she IS as sweet in person as she is on TV and she loves butter just as much as you think she does- I don’t care how much she’s changed her diet post diabetes.

But that’s neither here nor there. This blog entry is dedicated to the “Milk Mommies”,  the ladies who like myself are doing their darndest to keep the milk flowing for their little nursing ones.

I applaud all of you who are part of this club. Breast feeding is SO not the easy task that one might think it is nor does it come as second nature or as naturally as it seems it should. It’s hard work made harder when the baby you so wish to nourish doesn’t have an abundant milk supply. Some women’s boobs runneth over. Others of us must use supplements like Fenugreek, Blessed Thistle, Goat’s Rue, etc…but the tastiest thing I’ve come across thus far is Lactation Cookies- that I swear on my cracked nipples work.

There are several recipes out there, I’ve take a bit from here and there, but this is my own recipe that has made some of the best batches of cookies me and CJ, my non-lactating husband have ever had. Oh, and these cookies were a hit at “Baby Breastfeeding Bootcamp” so I can vouch for them.

Here is goes…

Ingredients:

  • 3 cups of steel cut/ old fashioned oatmeal
  • 2 cups of all-purpose flour
  • 1 and 1/2 cups of brown sugar
  • 1 cup of  chocolate chips (I prefer the milk chocolate morsels)
  • 1 cup of butter (I prefer salted)
  • 4 table spoons of water
  • 2-4 tablespoons of Brewers Yeast (be generous)
  • 2 tablespoons of Flaxseed Meal (I’ve used plain and the milled Flaxseed from Trader Joe’s with blueberries)
  • 1 teaspoon of vanilla extract
  • 1 teaspoon of salt
  • 1 teaspoon of cinnamon
  • 1 teaspoon of baking soda (yes like Arm & Hammers)

IMPORTANT! Do not substitute the brewers yeast… that’s the ingredient which makes them work.

Method:

Preparation time is around 15-20  minutes.
Preheat the oven to 350F.

1) Mix together 2 tablespoons of flaxseed meal and water, set aside for 3-5 minutes.
2) Cream (beat well) butter and brown sugar. Add eggs one at a time, mix well.
3) Stir flaxseed mixture and add with vanilla to the butter mix. Beat until blended.
4) Sift together dry ingredients, except oats and chips.
5) Add to butter mixture. Stir in oats then chips.
6) Scoop or drop onto baking sheet. The dough is a little crumbly, it might be easier if you use a scoop- I just use a spoon- no need to get too  fancy.

Bake for 8-12 minutes, depending on size of cookies. Makes approximately 6 dozen cookies.

*Again, I can only vouch for myself, but this definitely increased my milk supply and it was a delicious treat that was easy to make. A HUGE plus when you’re crazy busy with a newborn.

**Where to Get Brewers Yeast
You can get brewers yeast from health food stores, or in the health food isles of supermarkets. It’s a bit cheaper to buy brewers yeast from supermarkets than from health food stores.

As Paula Deen and I would say, HAPPY NURSING Y’ALL!!!

Leave a Reply

118 comments

  • i just made these cookies! I added cranberries I think they taste amazing! Maybe just need a little sugar to be perfect!

  • Does anyone know how many calories total one batch makes roughly? (I used 2 eggs and subbed 1/2 of the butter for applesauce).

  • You should used debittered brewers yeast so that the cookies won’t be bitter. It will give a sweeter cookie.

  • How many cookies did u eat a day?

  • do you know how many calories per cookie. I’m counting calories because I’ve been gaining too much weight while breastfeeding feeding. The cookies are the best I just want to be sure I’m not having too many a day.

  • Hi, me again😊 So I just calculated the calories and for one serving out of 36 it comes out to 151 per serving. If I’m wrong please correct me. I’d love to have actual calculations. Thank you!

  • Hey,

    I am trying to make these cookies but the ingredients don’t list eggs….however the instructions do. So Im just wondering how many eggs?

    🙂 Andrea

    I don’t know how to use this site (Im technologically impaired lmao) can you forward me your answer please, [email protected]

    xo

  • Just made these yesterday for a friend who had a baby last week. Really wishing the recipe made less because I do not need this many amazing cookies available. Haha, just kidding! For anyone who is wondering what my experience has been like: I used spelt flour instead of whole wheat flour, old fashioned oats instead of steel cut (though I have some steel cut that I would like to try), I used unsalted butter (which I always do for baking), though the recipe calls for adding eggs one at a time but you don’t actually need any eggs for the recipe and I added a cup of fresh frozen blueberries (we picked them then froze them). Holy crap. I have eaten waaaaayyyy too many of these already. Must give away the rest!

  • WOW!!! I made these cookies and just ate my first one and they are delicious. Even if they don’t help with my milk supply they are divine. I used 2 eggs and 4 tbsp of Brewers yeast. Followed the recipe exactly except for I split the batch and put peanut butter chips in half and chocolate chip in the other half. Looking forward to seeing if it will help my supply!!!

  • I doubled this recipe and have the cookies in the freezer for after baby comes… I used a 2TB scoop for the cookie dough and it made 79 cookies… my husband and daughter love them! I think they are super yummy! I used all organic ingredients and non-dairy chocolate chunks (not chips). The cooking time is spot on too; the cookies are perfectly soft in the middle but not underdone. Thanks for the awesome recipe!!

  • The instructions say to add eggs one at a time, but the ingredients don’t list any eggs! ?????

  • Has this recipe worked for anyone? I’m hoping to boost my supply. My baby is tongue tied, so until we get him clipped I’m pumping 8-10 times a day. How many cookies should I eat per day, 2?

  • avatar
    Marissa Kent-White

    How many eggs are we supposed to use? It doesn’t say the # in the list of ingredients, only in the recipe does it say to add them….

  • These will make good vegan cookies. Use vegan chocolate chips like enjoy life. Leave out the eggs. Sub coconut oil for butter. Reduce oats to 2.5 cups or keep at 3 and add water until you have a crumbly dough but sticky enough to stay together.

  • I have made a lot of lactation recipes and this one is the best! I used whole wheat flour and no oats. Awesome!

  • How many eggs in the cookies?

  • u don’t mention how many eggs

  • how many eggs do I use I’m making these for my girlfriend your ingredients list doesn’t have eggs on it but your directions do hope to hear from you soon

  • Can you freeze the mixture? Who needs to make 6 dozen cookies? Lol

  • Directions say to add eggs but that’s not in the ingredient list. Can you tell me how many eggs??

  • Can you freeze this and only take a little bit out at a time and cook?

  • I have made these twice now and they’ve come out good both times. I used 2 eggs and baking powder instead of baking soda. The first time I used dark chocolate chips and the second time I used mini Reeces Pieces. Each time I used 4 tablespoons of the Brewers yeast.

  • THESE ARE THE WORST COOKIES EVER. ******DO NOT MAKE THEM!!!!******
    The can’t even explain her recipe correctly.

  • I tried it with 2 eggs and must not have been enough because they just were solid balls

  • Quick question…. I know everyone’s body is different and what might work for you may not work for me. But how long after did you notice a increase of milk suply? ANY1…

  • How many eggs? I can’t find it?!?!?

  • How many eggs?

  • I read the ingredients so many times and I’m confused about the eggs. It doesn’t list how many eggs under ingredients but step 2 says mix eggs. We only used two. Maybe Thats why they didnt taste good ? 🙁

  • I should’ve read the comments first lol. I dont need reply. I did use 2 eggs. I added 4 big tablespoons of brewers yeast Thats probably why they don’t taste that good.

  • how many eggs? I don’t see them listed in the ingredients.

  • How much water do you use to mix with the flaxseed?

  • I made these tonight for myself and another nursing mama and we both loved them! I used 2 eggs, as suggested by other reviewers and slightly under-baked them. They were chewy and so delicious! I used 3 Tbsp of brewers yeast, but I will probably add 1-2 tbsps more next time I make them (the more yeast you use, the more milk production, right?). I would definitely recommend this recipe to anyone looking for a good lactation cookie.

  • Please add eggs to your ingredient list on lactation cookie recipe. You mention eggs in the directions.
    Going to try these today!!

  • I was interested in making your lactation cookies for my best friends daughter, but I noticed the directions call for adding the eggs one at a time, but no where in the recipe itself does it even call for eggs! What gives??

  • Is there a serving size or calorie count for these?

  • If I grind the steel cut oats into powder how much flour do I use

  • I made these cookies last night (1-20-16). I used old fashioned oats (the steel cut ones don’t seem to “cook”, left the cookies too dry and crunchy), 2 eggs, and I used BAKING POWDER. One of the previous posts said to look at other recipes like this one, and I did. They say baking powder also. I used 4 tbsp of the brewers yeast. I used Solgar Brewers Yeast from The Vitamin Shoppe. My first attempt at lactation cookies was with another recipe with brewers yeast from a beer brewing supply store. Let me say…NOT THE SAME YEAST. And it was more expensive there. The justmommies.com recipe turned out pretty well for me. Another person said these cookies were bitter….I don’t know what process they followed, but these are not super sweet by any means. The choc chips help. I will make these cookies again, with a few tweaks to see which variation tastes best. In my experience, the better way to boost supply is to nurse, nurse, nurse. Pump as often as you can. That’s how my supply dipped: I stopped pumping so much. I’m in the process of getting it back to the way it was. DO NOT GIVE UP MOMMIES! Breastmilk is indeed the best thing for your baby. If you don’t overflow the bottle you pump into, so what! Your baby appreciates what you are providing him/her, and just keeping trying. And if it’s not meant to be, don’t beat yourself up. Just know other moms have been there and ARE there with you. Chin up! Much love and respect, Jen.

  • Do you think it would hold if you made the dough & froze some, then thawed and cooked them?

  • Hi, just wondering how many should I eat at a time?

  • This makes 72 cookies?!?!? How small are your cookies? The size of a dime?

  • avatar
    Great recipe, but...

    This is a great recipe, but you do not mention how many eggs in the ingredients list.

  • How many eggs? There were no eggs on the ingredients list.

  • How many eggs? You don’t say how many are needed

  • How many eggs do I add

  • It says in the method add in eggs one at a time but the recipe do not require eggs in the ingredients? So how many eggs do I use?

  • It’s two eggs, guys. I tracked down someone who made it multiple times, and they said it’s two eggs. I’ve made it too, and 2 eggs is correct.

  • Reading through the comments, 2 eggs was the general consensus and mine turned out great! I used 3T of brewers yeast (reduced bitterness) and they taste awesome right out of the oven. Thanks for a tasty way to keep/boost milk supply!!

  • Just guessing here, but I think she may have adapted the recipe to be egg-free but forgot to take out the reference to eggs in the directions. Flax seed plus water is a common replacement for eggs; I made the cookies omitting eggs and using the flax seed + water binder that the recipe calls for and they turned out great.

  • How many eggs does the recipe call for? Thanks!

  • I used 4 eggs.
    They are absolutely delicious cookies and definitely worked for me at 4 months when my milk started to slow.
    Thank you!




×